Rosalie Avalon home

ROSALIE AVALON

Search the journal
,

Who Profits From Polarization? The Hidden Third Side of Our Digital World

Editorial illustration of a busy town square connected by digital networks, with a security guard and an ivory tower overlooking workplace and community interactions.

What a town square teaches us about cybersecurity, digital culture, workplace dynamics and the systems that divide us.

We live in a world of opposites.

Left versus right. Rich versus poor. Management versus employees. Security versus service. True versus false.

But what if we’re so busy choosing sides that we overlook a third perspective?

Who benefits from the division, and what keeps it alive?

Working in IT, communication and incident management has taught me that many problems aren’t necessarily technical. They’re problems of perspective, human behaviour and the systems connecting us.

To explain what I mean, I like to imagine society as a town square.

The Town Square: A Matter of Perspective

Picture a busy marketplace.

Buyers purchase, vendors sell, pickpockets steal and security guards protect. Families wander between stalls. Business owners negotiate.

Everyone shares the same square but experiences it differently.

Zoom in and you’ll discover individual motivations, personal circumstances and relationships. Zoom out and you’ll notice infrastructure, regulations, financial interests and power.

Now imagine an ivory tower overlooking the marketplace.

Its owners collect market fees and oversee operations. From above, they understand the infrastructure but might overlook the daily frustrations, broken processes and individual struggles below.

A bird’s-eye view reveals the system but often misses the human experience within it.

This applies to organisations and digital platforms alike.

A CEO manages stakeholders, strategy and reputation. Managers balance leadership expectations with operational realities. Employees experience the processes firsthand.

Meanwhile, social media platforms oversee millions of interactions through policies, moderation systems and algorithms. Community managers enforce rules, content creators compete for attention, and users experience the consequences.

Both environments have visible and invisible hierarchies.

And in both, those experiencing a problem are not necessarily those empowered to solve it.

When Silence Becomes the Norm

Imagine an employee raising concerns about intimidation, inappropriate behaviour or a toxic workplace atmosphere.

Management might interpret it as a personality conflict. HR sees an individual complaint. Senior leadership sees a department meeting its targets.

From above, everything appears functional.

But on the workfloor, people gradually stop questioning decisions or reporting problems because they fear retaliation or being labelled difficult.

Now consider the digital equivalent.

Someone questions a popular opinion, challenges misinformation or raises concerns about a community’s behaviour.

Instead of discussion, they encounter ridicule, harassment or an overwhelming wave of hostile responses.

Others watching may decide that remaining silent is safer.

This resembles what happens in workplaces where speaking up carries social or professional consequences.

Of course, disagreement and accountability are not the same as harassment. Harmful behaviour should be challenged, online and offline. Psychological safety doesn’t mean freedom from criticism; it means being able to participate, question and report concerns without intimidation.

A quiet workplace isn’t necessarily healthy. Neither is an online community where everyone appears to agree.

Both may simply have taught people that speaking up comes at a price.

The Invisible Third Side

We often look at conflicts as two opposing groups.

But I find it more interesting to examine the incentives surrounding them.

In workplaces, competing performance targets can unintentionally reward departmental rivalry. In digital media, outrage can generate clicks, engagement and advertising revenue.

Even beyond these environments, similar dynamics appear. Defence industries may benefit financially from increased military spending, while religious institutions can compete over the authority to define and interpret truth.

That doesn’t mean every conflict has a hidden mastermind or that financial interests explain every disagreement.

Sometimes the third side isn’t another person. It’s the system rewarding the behaviour.

A workplace might reward employees for resolving tickets quickly rather than solving recurring problems. A social media platform might amplify provocative content because it attracts attention.

Different environments. Similar feedback loops.

This is why I value root-cause analysis. Instead of merely asking who is wrong, we should examine why the problem continues.

Digital Culture Is Workplace Culture on a Larger Scale

We often treat digital culture as something separate from everyday life.

But online communities develop many of the same dynamics as organisations: informal leaders, social hierarchies, group loyalty, conflicts, reputations and unwritten rules.

A popular creator can influence public opinion much like a senior leader influences workplace culture. Moderators can shape participation much like managers. Members who challenge established norms risk exclusion, just as employees sometimes do.

The difference is scale and speed.

An uncomfortable workplace conversation might involve ten people. A misunderstood social media post can reach thousands before the author has an opportunity to clarify.

Algorithms can contribute to that visibility, although research shows their influence on polarization varies between platforms.

The problem isn’t necessarily disagreement itself. It’s what happens when disagreement becomes entertainment, when belonging requires conformity, or when being right matters more than understanding.

And the consequences don’t remain online. They enter workplaces, friendships, communities and institutions.

Our digital culture increasingly shapes how we treat one another in the physical world.

Cybersecurity Begins With Human Trust

These dynamics have consequences for cybersecurity.

If an employee fears admitting a mistake, an incident may remain unreported. If a community distrusts its moderators, legitimate warnings may be ignored.

And when fear becomes the dominant emotion, manipulation becomes easier.

Scammers exploit urgency, authority and uncertainty. AI-generated voices and manipulated content make it increasingly important to verify what we encounter.

Yet we should also question our own certainty.

Research into the misinformation effect demonstrates that human memory can be distorted by information received after an event. What we remember isn’t always identical to what happened.

That doesn’t mean truth is subjective. It means conclusions should be grounded in evidence rather than confidence alone.

We can imagine a thousand and one things that might go wrong. Most never happen, while the credible risks require proportionate action rather than endless paranoia.

This is why I increasingly prefer the concept of cyber resilience.

Cybersecurity is essential, but absolute safety cannot be guaranteed. Resilience means recognising risks, responding effectively, recovering and learning.

The same principle applies to a healthy workplace or online community: people should be able to recognise problems, raise concerns and contribute to solutions.

From Ivory Towers to Grassroots Change

What concerns me most is the distance between recognising a problem and having the authority to address it.

Online platforms such as LinkedIn and X give people opportunities to reach audiences and decision-makers. Yet visibility doesn’t guarantee influence.

Money, professional networks, privilege and sometimes sheer luck still affect whose ideas are heard.

That’s why grassroots initiatives appeal to me. They allow change to begin with people experiencing the problem instead of waiting for instructions from above.

I’d like to see more Agile thinking applied beyond IT: shorter feedback loops, cross-functional collaboration and genuine opportunities for bottom-up improvement.

Leadership and accountability remain necessary. But decisions shouldn’t only travel downward while concerns struggle upward.

A resilient organisation or digital community needs both perspectives: those who understand the bigger picture and those who experience its consequences.

Repairing the Square

I don’t believe we need a world without disagreement. Different perspectives are essential to understanding complicated systems.

But disagreement should create opportunities to learn rather than permanent divisions.

Cybersecurity teaches us to identify vulnerabilities. Incident management teaches us to examine root causes. Workplace and digital culture remind us that human behaviour connects everything.

Perhaps we should spend less time defending our side and more time understanding the structures surrounding us.

Zoom in. Listen to individual experiences.

Zoom out. Examine the incentives.

Then connect what you’ve learned.

Because the most important question may not be who wins the argument.

It’s who profits while we remain divided—and what we could build if we started repairing the square together.

Previous essay
Next essay